Return to site

Two leadership approaches:

Top down versus bottom up

Choosing between collaboration loss or captivity

January 27, 2019

Situation

  1. Variety and overlap assume organizations that are similar to the networks.
  2. There are multiple actors involved in decision-making.
  3. As nodes in a network, these actors like nodes are related to each other .
  4. Every proposed decision will result in a push and pull among several of these nodes with unpredictable outcomes.

How to decide in such a networked organization?

Top-Down approach

  • Definition: the leader using her formal authority directly (command and control)
  • Pros: clear, peace
  • Cons: makes organization reactive, little potential for cooperative behavior

Bottom-up approach:

  • Definition: telling organizational members what to do, the leader is trusting the lower levels to generate their own problems and solutions
  • Pros: respects people's knowledge, potential for cooperative behavior
  • Cons: leader may become captive